All the cookie recipes listed from top-ranked to the Recipe Flops.

​

1. Lemon Snaps (1921) - 9.2

2. Waffle Hermits (1947) - 8.7

3. Pecan or Angel Slices (1964) - 8.5

4. Cocoanut Puffs (1913) - 8.3

5. Boston Cookies (1921) - 8.25

6. Cottage Cheese Cookies (1959) - 8.1

7. Cry Babies (1932) - 7.6

8. Double Deck Brownies (1962) - 7.4

9. Peanut Whirligigs (1951) - 7.25

10. Honey Ginger Cookies (1943) - 7.0

11. Excellent Cookies (1902) - 7.0

12. Wasp Nest Cookies (1949) - RECIPE FLOP, No Ranking